You Can’t Rely on the 21-Day Habit Rule: A Scientific Approach
Written on
Understanding the 21-Day Myth
The widely held belief that it takes just twenty-one days to establish a new habit has become a common mantra. This notion, while appealing, often leads to disappointment for those genuinely seeking self-improvement. People tend to think that a mere three weeks is a manageable duration to make a significant change. However, when we reflect on personal experiences, this idea quickly unravels.
Take waking up early, for example. Despite years of attempting to rise around 7 am, I still find it challenging to maintain this habit consistently. Whenever there’s an opportunity to sleep in, I often take it, demonstrating that simply adhering to the 21-day rule doesn’t guarantee success.
Where Did the 21-Day Rule Originate?
The misconception can be traced back to the 1950s when a plastic surgeon observed that it typically took individuals approximately 21 days to adjust to their "new face" after surgery. This observation was popularized in his bestselling book, "Psycho-Cybernetics," which sold over 30 million copies. The author, Maxwell Maltz, suggested that it required about three weeks for a new mental image to form.
As self-help authors embraced Maltz’s findings, the idea that 21 days was the magic number for habit formation proliferated. This led many to believe that enduring a tough period for 21 days would magically switch on their desired habits.
The Science of Habit Formation
Research indicates that this mindset is fundamentally flawed. To successfully cultivate a habit, it’s essential to identify and eliminate the barriers that hinder progress. Rather than viewing habit formation as a chore, it’s more effective to frame it in a way that ignites motivation.
Humans naturally tend to conserve energy, often opting for the path of least resistance. This tendency can lead to unhealthy choices, such as fast food or neglecting exercise. However, by strategically increasing the resistance when trying to break a bad habit or reducing it when attempting to adopt a new one, we can facilitate the development of positive habits.
The Role of Resistance in Habit Formation
One of my favorite authors posited that we are not inherently lazy, bored, or unmotivated. When we struggle to change, it’s often due to external factors or ineffective approaches. Instead of forcing ourselves uphill, we can ease our journey by creating a smoother path for habit adoption.
For instance, I found success in waking up earlier by establishing an enjoyable morning routine. By making the choice to rise early more appealing and increasing the difficulty of staying up late, I successfully integrated this habit into my life.
Viewing Setbacks as Learning Opportunities
It’s easy to view failure in habit formation as a personal shortcoming. However, not succeeding on the first attempt simply provides additional insights. Research by Lally et al. suggests that a single missed opportunity to engage in a desired behavior does not significantly hinder the habit formation process.
For example, I aspired to eat healthier dinners instead of resorting to quick and unhealthy options. After devising a meal plan, I still ended up ordering pizza one evening. Rather than giving up, I considered this a learning experience and shifted my strategy to grocery delivery, which simplified the process of eating well.
Embracing the Journey of Habit Formation
Habit formation isn’t a mystical endeavor governed by arbitrary timelines. It involves self-awareness and understanding. If a habit is truly valuable to you, the goal is to make it easier to engage in it than to avoid it. This journey may require experimentation, but it is the only sustainable method for long-term success.
Only you can determine what strategies will resonate, and it’s crucial to view failures as guidance rather than self-criticism. There’s no need for a divine intervention or a specific timeline to achieve meaningful habits; rather, it’s about making the desired behavior the simplest option available to you.
The first video titled "THE 20 SECOND RULE - HOW TO BUILD A NEW HABIT" provides insights into how to effectively create new habits and the psychological principles behind habit formation.
The second video titled "NEUROSCIENTIST: 'Build Life Lasting Habits In Just 21 Days'" discusses how to approach habit building from a scientific perspective, debunking the myth of the 21-day rule.
By shifting your mindset and focusing on making the desired habits easier to adopt, you can start shaping your life in a way that aligns with your aspirations.