Unraveling Peto's Paradox: Understanding Cancer Across Species
Written on
Chapter 1: The Mystery of Cancer Rates in Different Species
Peto's Paradox poses a fascinating question: If cancer arises from genetic mutations in a single cell, one might expect larger animals, which contain more cells, to have higher cancer rates. Surprisingly, this is not the case!
This phenomenon, named after epidemiologist Richard Peto, was uncovered during his research on cancer development in mice. Peto noted that the duration of exposure to carcinogens correlates with cancer risk. He found it perplexing that humans, who have approximately 10,000 times more cells and live significantly longer than mice, exhibit similar cancer rates. Furthermore, cancer is seldom a leading cause of death among larger wild animals, despite their increased theoretical risk.
How can we explain this discrepancy?
Section 1.1: Understanding Cell Division and Cancer Risk
In multicellular organisms, cells undergo cycles of growth and division. Each time a cell divides, it replicates its DNA, which can lead to errors known as somatic mutations. If these mutations occur in genes that promote cancer or hinder the cell’s defenses, the cell may become cancerous.
If every cell has a certain probability of accumulating harmful mutations, one would expect that larger, longer-lived organisms face a greater risk of cancer due to more cell divisions. However, a study in 2015 analyzing zoo necropsy data for 36 mammals revealed no correlation between body mass or lifespan and cancer incidence. In fact, larger mammals seem to experience lower cancer rates.
This suggests that nature has evolved mechanisms to reduce cancer risk in these larger species. Could understanding Peto's Paradox lead to new cancer prevention strategies?
Section 1.2: Potential Explanations for Peto's Paradox
To address Peto's Paradox, we can consider evolutionary mechanisms. When a species faces cancer as a selective pressure, they must adapt to survive. However, the specific biological mechanisms behind this adaptation vary across different species.
Today, we will explore three intriguing theories that help explain Peto's Paradox.
Subsection 1.2.1: Elephants and TP53
When cells experience DNA damage, they can either repair the damage or undergo apoptosis (programmed cell death). The TP53 gene plays a critical role in triggering apoptosis. Remarkably, African elephants possess 20 copies of TP53, compared to humans, who only have one. This suggests that elephants are better equipped to eliminate potentially cancerous cells.
Experiments have shown that elephant cells are more likely to activate apoptosis when exposed to damaging radiation, effectively reducing the risk of cancer. However, this mechanism does not universally apply to all large mammals, as evidenced by the lack of additional TP53 copies in whales.
Section 1.3: Metabolic Rates and Cancer
Another theory posits that larger animals may have lower cancer rates due to their generally lower metabolic rates. Higher metabolic rates produce more harmful agents, particularly reactive oxygen species, which can damage DNA. Consequently, larger animals may face less exposure to these damaging agents, reducing their cancer risk.
Chapter 2: The Hypertumour Theory
Lastly, we delve into the captivating theory of hypertumours. This theory suggests that larger tumours in big animals take longer to grow and are vulnerable to "cheater cells," which exploit the tumor's resources, thereby diminishing the overall aggressiveness of the cancer.
These three theories provide valuable insights into Peto's Paradox, though no single explanation has emerged as definitive. Many other theories exist, but we will not cover them all here. Links to further information on each theory will be provided in the video description.
The first video titled "The Medical Paradox That Keeps Doctors Awake at Night" delves into the nuances of Peto's Paradox and its implications for cancer research.
Why is this important?
Understanding how cancer suppression has evolved in various species can inform better therapeutic strategies. However, the ongoing sixth mass extinction poses a threat; the loss of species may mean losing potential solutions to cancer, one of humanity's leading health challenges.
As we unravel these complex biological mechanisms, it becomes increasingly vital to appreciate the importance of biodiversity and the conservation of species worldwide.
The second video titled "These Paradoxes Keep Scientists Awake At Night!" provides further insights into the challenges and wonders of cancer research and prevention.
The Dev Doctor is dedicated to creating content on Healthcare, Medical Technology, and Science | Patreon
is creating Healthcare, Medical Tech & Science related videos. Select a membership level to support ongoing research and education.
www.patreon.com