The Truth Behind How Water Drains: Myths and Realities Explored
Written on
Understanding Water Drainage Directions
My daughter recently traveled to Australia, and I asked her to conduct a little experiment by flushing toilets and filling sinks to observe the direction of the water as it drained. It’s amusing to have a daughter who is involved in scientific inquiries! Most people believe that water drains counterclockwise in the Northern Hemisphere—similar to hurricanes—and clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere. However, after multiple tests, she concluded, “The jury is still out.”
What I didn’t mention to her, which she will discover in this article, is that the idea that water drains in a specific direction based on your location is largely a myth. Nevertheless, there is a small kernel of truth in this idea, intertwined with fascinating global physics and some basic principles of plumbing.
The Big Picture Overview
Throughout the year, the sun shines more directly on the equator than on the poles, leading to consistently warmer temperatures in that region. Warm air molecules are more energized, causing them to spread out, resulting in lower pressure. This warm air rises and then flows toward the poles, where it cools and sinks. The colder air, being denser, has higher pressure and moves back toward the equator at the surface, gradually warming up along the way.
If the Earth were stationary, air would simply travel back and forth between the equator and the polar regions, as depicted in the previous graphic.
The Influence of Earth's Rotation
However, our planet rotates on its axis every 24 hours. This rotation not only causes the sun to rise but also results in curved wind patterns. Think of a spinning record: if you draw a line from the center to the edge, the line appears curved due to the record's motion. Similarly, Earth's rotation causes winds in the Northern Hemisphere to curve to the right.
This phenomenon is known as the Coriolis effect, named after French engineer and mathematician Gustave-Gaspard Coriolis, who first described it in 1835. The Coriolis effect is responsible for the counterclockwise rotation of cyclones (like hurricanes) in the Northern Hemisphere. Here’s how it works:
In a cyclone, the center has lower air pressure compared to its surroundings, causing air to rush toward the center. However, the air is continuously deflected to the right, resulting in a counterclockwise rotation.
In contrast, cyclones in the Southern Hemisphere rotate clockwise due to the reverse effect. This principle applies not only to severe storms but also to all cyclonic weather systems. The Coriolis effect influences large-scale air movements and contributes to ocean currents, though interestingly, hurricanes do not form at the equator due to the lack of prevailing winds.
Local Physics vs. Global Dynamics
Despite the significant influence of the Coriolis effect on weather patterns, it does not determine the direction in which water drains in sinks, toilets, or bathtubs. The drainage direction is influenced primarily by the shape of the drain, the water's entry direction, and any disturbances in the water, such as movements caused by your hand or objects placed in it. Even the way standing water drains is more affected by the design of the sink or drain than by the Coriolis effect.
However, there are intriguing exceptions that blur the line between theoretical and practical physics. According to Alistair B. Fraser, a meteorology professor emeritus at Penn State University, it is theoretically possible to design an experiment that demonstrates a consistent effect of the Coriolis force on water draining from a perfectly constructed drain under ideal conditions.
To achieve this, one would need a symmetrical, smooth pan approximately 3 feet in diameter with a very small central hole. If the water remains perfectly still for an extended period and drains slowly, the Coriolis effect could create a consistent counterclockwise motion in a Northern Hemisphere setting.
Nonetheless, real-world plumbing fixtures are rarely perfect, and their designs, along with various localized factors, determine the direction water swirls down the drain. Essentially, the Coriolis effect has negligible impact on everyday drainage scenarios.
More Aha! Moments >>>
Thank you for your support that allows me to continue my reporting and writing. For further insights, consider checking out my book: Make Sleep Your Superpower. Additionally, if you're an aspiring writer, subscribe to my Writer’s Guide newsletter. Note: Some parts of this article have been published previously.
Exploring the Coriolis Effect
The first video explores the intriguing question: "Does Water Swirl the Other Way in the Southern Hemisphere?" It delves into the myths and realities surrounding water drainage direction, providing a deeper understanding of the Coriolis effect.
Understanding the Coriolis Effect in Everyday Life
The second video titled "The Coriolis Effect: Does draining water's swirl direction really change either side of the equator?" offers insights into how this phenomenon impacts our daily lives and challenges common misconceptions about water drainage.