The Struggle for Fossils: O.C. Marsh and the Dinosaur Wars
Written on
The Rise of O.C. Marsh
Othniel Charles Marsh, a Yale paleontologist from the 1870s, was a determined figure who encountered Native Americans and explored the rugged landscapes of the American West. Although he was a prominent academic, his ambition to become the foremost fossil hunter led to one of the darkest periods in American scientific history.
Driven by his quest for fossils, Marsh made several iconic discoveries, including the Triceratops and Stegosaurus, and he was instrumental in piecing together the evolutionary history of horses. His publication detailing the horse's fossil record included illustrations that showcased the gradual changes in the equine forefoot.
Marsh’s contributions to evolutionary science were significant, particularly his remarkable work on horse fossils, which left a lasting impact on contemporaries such as Thomas H. Huxley. Huxley's pivotal moment of enlightenment came after he reviewed Marsh's horse fossils, leading him to present a groundbreaking lecture on evolution in New York City.
Nevertheless, Marsh's simplistic view of evolution—portraying it as a linear progression—captured both public and academic interest, despite its inaccuracies. This perspective erroneously positioned humans at the pinnacle of evolution, overlooking the complex and branching nature of evolutionary history.
Darwin's theory of evolution, as expressed in his seminal work On the Origin of Species, described evolution as a branching tree, with species evolving into varieties and eventually new species over time.
Marsh did correctly assert that birds evolved from dinosaurs, positing that the skeletal structures of some dinosaurs were indistinguishable from those of Jurassic birds.
A Troubled Childhood
O.C. Marsh was born in Lockport, New York, in 1831, to Caleb Marsh and Mary Gaines Peabody. His mother was the sister of George Peabody, a wealthy philanthropist who played a crucial role in Marsh's future endeavors.
Tracing his roots back to early American settlers, Marsh's family history was rich, with both sides claiming notable ancestry. His parents met at Bradford Academy, married in 1827, and soon after purchased a farm near the Erie Canal. However, tragedy struck when they lost their firstborn son in 1828.
In 1834, following the birth of his fourth child, Mary Marsh passed away from cholera, leaving Caleb devastated. He eventually remarried, but financial difficulties plagued the family for years. O.C. Marsh grew up avoiding farm work, preferring to explore nature and develop his marksmanship.
The region gained fame for its Silurian fossils, attracting paleontologists like Colonel Ezekiel Jewett, who taught Marsh the art of fossil collection. Marsh's education was sporadic, yet he managed to attend prestigious institutions, eventually securing funding from his wealthy uncle to study at Yale.
The Influence of George Peabody
George Peabody, born into a humble family, overcame adversity to become a successful banker and financier. Despite his busy career, he remained supportive of his nephew O.C. Marsh, providing both encouragement and financial assistance for his education.
Marsh's academic pursuits took him to Europe, where he studied under prominent scientists and engaged with Peabody, who pledged substantial financial support for a museum at Yale. This led to the establishment of the Peabody Museum of Natural History, where Marsh was later appointed as Chair of Paleontology.
The Bone Wars
Marsh's most significant rival was Edward Drinker Cope, born in 1840 to a wealthy family. Despite their similar backgrounds and shared passion for paleontology, their personalities and ambitions set the stage for an intense rivalry.
Cope's affluent upbringing allowed him opportunities that Marsh did not have, and he pursued education in prestigious institutions. The two initially formed a friendship, but this quickly soured as competitive tensions escalated.
The rivalry ignited in 1868, when Marsh undermined Cope by bribing quarry owners to send fossils to him instead of Cope. Their feud escalated further when Marsh publicly ridiculed Cope's misidentification of a giant plesiosaur, marking the beginning of the notorious Bone Wars—a bitter, decades-long competition.
The conflict involved various underhanded tactics, including sabotaging digs, stealing fossils, and discrediting each other in academic circles. Despite Marsh discovering eighty new dinosaur species compared to Cope's fifty-six, both men's legacies suffered irreparable damage, tarnished by their reckless rivalry.
The Bone Wars also led to significant collateral damage, disrupting the careers of others and leaving a lasting impact on American paleontology. Despite the chaos, the fossils they uncovered—such as Triceratops, Stegosaurus, and Allosaurus—remain iconic, filling museums and captivating the imaginations of many.
The Legacy of the Bone Wars
The rivalry between Marsh and Cope serves as a cautionary tale about ambition and integrity in science. Their legacies, filled with both remarkable discoveries and monumental failures, continue to influence paleontology and the public’s understanding of evolution.
The Bone Wars: Edward Drinker Cope & Othniel Marsh - YouTube
American Experience - Dinosaur Wars (2011) - YouTube