Chapter 1: The Struggle with AI and Authenticity

As I lie awake, staring at the ceiling, my thoughts race about the rapidly advancing world of artificial intelligence and its implications for writers like myself.

I often feel a growing sense of displacement as I browse through social media, flooded with stories of authors achieving astonishing success overnight. These writers share their ideas with AI models like Claude and ChatGPT, which promptly generate full novels in mere hours.

While it's true that efficiency is often linked to achievement, the rise of AI writing tools, such as Writer, raises a critical question: could this efficiency be a hidden threat to the very essence of writing?

May Habib, co-founder and CEO of Writer, engages in a conversation with Kirk Ball, EVP and CIO of Giant Eagle Inc., about the importance of investing in data to stay ahead in the industry. Although AI tools are praised for automating tasks and saving companies substantial amounts of money, their effects on the creative process remain ambiguous.

Section 1.1: The Dimensions of Writing

Writers navigate three key dimensions: creating, editing, analyzing, researching, and transforming content. While these capabilities can enhance productivity, they also pose risks to the art of writing.

#### Subsection 1.1.1: The Perils of Automated Creativity

When AI dominates the creative process, it threatens to dilute the individual voice and style of the writer, resulting in homogenized content that lacks the human touch. The ease of research may prompt writers to cut corners, potentially sacrificing the depth and nuance that manual research offers. Furthermore, the ability to repurpose content can lead to a culture that favors recycling over originality.

I have friends who are writers and have also become ensnared in the AI trap. One such friend excitedly shared in our writing group chat how he used Claude and ChatGPT to whip up the first draft of his sci-fi novel in just one weekend by merely outlining his characters and setting.

Yes, I admit I feel a twinge of envy.

While these authors find a fast track to success, my own journey has been a laborious process of endless drafts, revisions, and persistent rejections, alongside gradual improvements in my craft over many years. Although I have seen moderate success, it has come from a decade of slow growth in audience and publication credits, rather than sudden fame.

Despite the impressive capabilities of AI models like Claude, I suspect their appeal may be short-lived, quickly becoming a novelty as the market floods with AI-generated books.

Section 1.2: The Value of Human Storytelling

Call me old-fashioned, but I believe storytelling retains lasting value rooted in the messy complexities of human experience. The distinct voices and the emotional investments of writers give their works a depth that AI cannot replicate.

I recently encountered a thought-provoking essay by literary critic Michiko Kakutani, which resonated deeply with my concerns. She stated, "For all of the AI's prodigious abilities, it fundamentally lacks the crucial element of autobiography that anchors fiction in a rich emotional truth." No matter how advanced the model, it cannot convey the personal pain, joy, and wisdom derived from human experience, which elevates a story from mere words to resonant art.

Kakutani further notes that "stories generated solely from algorithms and training datasets are destined to be imitations of imitations."

I reflect on my friend, Raymond Chandler, who infused her heartache from a recent divorce into her powerful literary work, "The Long Goodbye." During our late-night discussions over wine, I witnessed her raw honesty, which permeated every line of her book. Readers connected with her searing authenticity because it stemmed from her painful truths.

Although I might seem to be rationalizing my feelings of envy over my friends' rapid success, the fleeting nature and uniformity of AI-generated works unsettle me.

Chapter 2: Embracing the Slow Path

I take pride in my role as a slow but steady writer.

My stories on platforms like Medium and Substack develop at a much slower pace compared to the rapid output of AI. Yes, I envy those who seem to have found shortcuts, bypassing the traditional struggles of writing through technology.

However, I want my writing to emerge from a place of authenticity—rich inner worlds of subjective experiences, emotions, and insights into the human psyche. While my progress may be painstaking, I trust that it will ultimately yield a more meaningful impact than any shortcut could provide.

I will continue my artistic journey, regardless of how long it takes or how AI disrupts the literary landscape. I can rest easy, knowing that my work is born from a primal, sacred source that machines can never replicate.

My blogs and stories may never grace bestseller lists, but I will go to bed with a sense of self-worth and pride in my craft.

Finally, I would like to share insights from Sierra Elman regarding her views on AI in writing.

Connect with me on Twitter, read more engaging blogs on Medium, subscribe to my Substack Newsletter, and check out my YouTube channel.

In this video titled "This AI NEWS Gives Me Sleepless NIGHTS," the discussion revolves around the emotional toll that AI's rise in the writing world takes on traditional authors.

The second video, "AI's Role in Sleep Medicine," explores how AI technologies impact various fields, including creative writing and mental health.