# Rethinking Consciousness: The Brain as a Permitting Entity
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Consciousness
In contemporary science, the prevailing notion is that consciousness is merely an epiphenomenon of brain activity. Despite the lack of any substantial resolution to David Chalmers' Hard Problem—suggesting that mapping the brain's structure will not unveil consciousness—this idea endures among many scholars. The belief that a hidden feature of the brain will eventually explain consciousness persists, despite its metaphysical implications, which many in the scientific community dismiss as too spiritual.
However, the exploration of consciousness remains a vital area for scientific inquiry, as alternative perspectives may offer valuable insights into its nature.
Section 1.1: The Epiphenomenal Perspective
The common epiphenomenal view posits that the brain generates consciousness, akin to how an air conditioning unit releases air. This assumption is particularly prevalent among materialists, yet it presents significant challenges. Primarily, it fails to clarify the origin of consciousness, which seems fundamentally distinct from the material world.
To understand consciousness better, we can consider a second perspective: rather than being emitted by the brain, consciousness is permitted by it. This suggests that consciousness is an intrinsic aspect of reality, and the brain acts more like a filter, allowing certain experiences of consciousness to surface.
Subsection 1.1.1: Evidence from Psychedelics
Psychedelic substances provide compelling evidence for this viewpoint. Many pioneers in the psychedelic movement, such as Aldous Huxley, experienced altered states that led them to believe in a universal consciousness beyond the individual self. Huxley's reflections in his work, The Doors of Perception, echo the idea that cleansing our perception can reveal a more expansive reality.
Recent studies indicate that psychedelic use correlates with reduced activity in the brain's default mode network (DMN), which is often linked to the ego. This reduction mirrors the brain activity of seasoned meditators, suggesting that both practices may facilitate a broader cognitive connection by deactivating the self-restrictive aspects of consciousness.
Section 1.2: The Role of the Default Mode Network
The DMN seems to act like a conductor in an orchestra, managing and limiting other brain functions. When psychedelics diminish DMN activity, they enable a more fluid exchange between brain areas, contributing to the vivid experiences often reported during such states. This loss of self, rather than diminishing consciousness, appears to enhance it.
Chapter 2: The Universal Consciousness
The first video, The Brain Doesn't Create Consciousness — It Constrains It, explores the concept of consciousness as a fundamental element of existence rather than a byproduct of neurological processes. This perspective aligns with both ancient philosophies and contemporary insights, suggesting a more profound understanding of consciousness.
The second video, Does Consciousness Extend Beyond Brains? The 2023 Holberg Debate, features a discussion on the implications of consciousness existing beyond mere brain function, shedding light on the ongoing debate in scientific and philosophical circles.
As we analyze the experiences of individuals—be they meditators, artists, or those under the influence of psychedelics—it raises the question of whether these moments allow us to glimpse a universal consciousness that transcends the limitations imposed by the ego. It seems implausible that consciousness is merely a product of brain activity; rather, it suggests that consciousness has always existed and our lives are spent navigating its boundaries.
Throughout history, poets and artists have captured this notion. In Intimations of Immortality, Wordsworth reflects on the loss of childlike wonder as one grows older, hinting at a pre-existing state of joyful awareness. Similarly, Don Paterson argues that poetry allows us to touch upon the essence of consciousness that predates language.
By considering consciousness as something that the brain permits rather than generates, we open ourselves to a more integrated view of brain function and consciousness. The prevailing epiphenomenal stance fails to satisfactorily explain the nature of consciousness and its role in our lives.
In summary, while scientific instruments may still be catching up, the insights of poets and mystics resonate deeply with the human experience of consciousness. As Blake articulated, the potential to perceive reality in its infinite form remains, waiting for us to unlock its doors.