Shifting Standards of Perception

In a 2018 study published in Science, researchers examined the flexibility of human perception, coining the term “perceptual creep.” This concept parallels ideas like “feature creep” in product development and “mission creep” in military operations. The researchers focused on how the context could alter perceptions over time.

In their initial experiment, participants were shown a series of colored dots and tasked with identifying them as blue or purple. Each participant viewed 1,000 dots individually, with the left side of the spectrum classified as purple and the right as blue.

Initially, the first 200 dots were evenly split between the two colors. However, for half of the participants (the experimental group), the distribution changed, with fewer blue dots appearing as the experiment progressed. Ultimately, the last 650 dots presented only a 6% chance of being blue, leading participants to increasingly label purple dots as blue.

The control group, however, maintained a steady 50/50 ratio throughout, resulting in consistent labeling of the colors. The experimental group, conversely, displayed a significant shift in perception, even when informed about the decreasing likelihood of blue dots appearing.

The researchers sought to explore whether this phenomenon would extend to more critical situations. They conducted additional experiments where participants evaluated human faces based on perceived threat levels and assessed ethical considerations in research proposals. In both scenarios, a decrease in the prevalence of certain stimuli led participants to redefine their perceptions.

The first video, Why You Should Question Your Reality, delves into the importance of examining your own perceptions and beliefs. It highlights how questioning your reality can lead to personal growth and a more nuanced understanding of the world.

The second video, Does questioning reality lead you to madness? | Donald Hoffman and Lex Fridman, explores the implications of questioning one's reality and its potential effects on mental health.

Consequences of Perceptual Creep

The findings from the ethics board experiment reveal that perceptual creep can significantly alter perceptions of right and wrong. This adaptability may help identify historical injustices but can also mislead moral judgments in contemporary contexts. The researchers maintained neutrality, acknowledging that such perceptual shifts could have both positive and negative ramifications.

In summary, perceptual creep demonstrates that subjective realities can fluctuate dramatically based on context. It is crucial to remain aware of this phenomenon to avoid overconfidence in personal views, which may change at any moment.

Key Takeaways

1. Adaptable Perception: Recognize that your understanding of reality can shift based on surrounding context.
2. Acknowledge Progress: Stay mindful of how far you’ve come, both personally and socially, to appreciate progress and avoid mislabeling ethical actions.
3. Embrace Ambiguity: Be aware of the complexities in decision-making, balancing sensitivity to ethical violations with the risk of falsely condemning innocent actions.

“Normally, we take our reference frame for granted; we mistake it for ‘reality.’”

~ K. C. Cole, The Universe and the Teacup (1998)

This article was originally published in my free weekly newsletter (The Brainlift) at erman.substack.com. Sign up at this link for regular, science-backed tips to improve your health and happiness.