Chapter 1: The Power of Imagination

In a previous article, I explored how visualizing yourself engaging in activities that you find challenging—like hitting the gym or asking questions at a conference—can increase your desire to participate and improve your follow-through. In essence, the mantra is simple: envision it, and you will accomplish it.

However, I also touched on a significant drawback: daydreaming about aspirations (like attaining wealth, becoming a CEO, or receiving a Nobel Prize) might dampen your motivation, ultimately obstructing your progress. This phenomenon occurs because your mind may trick itself into believing it has already achieved its desires, thus diminishing the urgency typically necessary to pursue those goals.

Here, I will delve into a different aspect of the imagination's usefulness: managing negative emotions.

Do you feel nervous when speaking to someone you find appealing? Or do you experience anxiety before making a call or sitting for an exam? Engaging your imagination might be the key to addressing these feelings.

My insights are heavily influenced by the work of Andrea Rivadulla-Duró (forthcoming).

Photo by Etienne Boulanger on Unsplash

Addressing Phobias and Emotional Challenges

Phobias can be particularly tough to conquer because our brains often do not get the opportunity to learn that specific stimuli are safe. For instance, if you've been bitten by a dog, your brain links dogs—especially being near them—with danger, prompting a fear response. For your brain to alter this automatic reaction, it would need to recognize that being close to dogs is harmless.

Yet, how can this learning occur if the individual avoids such encounters? And how can one refrain from avoidance when the mere thought of it induces discomfort? It appears to be a daunting cycle.

Fortunately, there is a well-known method employed to address this dilemma: exposure therapy (Eaton et al., 2018). This approach involves gradually confronting the feared stimulus. With repeated exposure, the brain begins to associate the stimulus with the absence of negative outcomes. In simpler terms, you come to understand that the adverse events you anticipate are unlikely to happen, which gradually diminishes your fear response until the fear dissipates.

While this concept works exceptionally well in theory, practical implementation can be fraught with challenges. First, there may be logistical issues, such as locating the feared object (like dogs or spiders) and ensuring consistent practice. Second, and perhaps most importantly, initiating the process can be incredibly daunting.

You might agree in the therapist's office that exposure therapy is worthwhile, but being in proximity to the feared object may trigger an instinct to flee, abandon the effort, or even faint. You may find yourself so overwhelmed that you skip the session altogether, avoiding the situation before you even arrive.

Fortunately, there is a way to initiate exposure therapy without needing to be physically close to the feared object: through the power of imagination (Anthony & Swinson, 2000).

Photo by Vadim Bogulov on Unsplash

Research indicates that visualizing successful interactions with the feared stimulus—such as imagining yourself petting a calm dog or playing with it in a park—serves two crucial functions.

First, it can evoke fear, similar to the experience of being near a real dog (Grayson, 1982). This is significant: our brains process imagined scenarios similarly to actual sensory experiences, activating the same neural pathways. For instance, viewing a butterfly stimulates visual areas in the occipital lobe, just as imagining one does (Kosslyn et al., 2006). This overlap in processing helps explain why we can feel fear towards imagined situations (Van Leeuwen, 2016). If we did not experience fear in our imagination, it wouldn't effectively serve as a substitute for real exposure therapy.

Second, this imaginative practice helps to reduce your fear response, much like traditional exposure therapy does (Choy et al., 2007; Hackmann et al., 2011; and others).

The key takeaway is that imagination can disrupt the connections your brain has formed between certain stimuli (like dogs) and anticipated negative outcomes (like bites). By doing so, it effectively diminishes your fear response.

This technique can serve as a valuable preliminary step toward actual exposure therapy with real dogs. It is adaptable and can be practiced anywhere, and if your fear response intensifies, you can simply pause your visualization and redirect your focus until you feel calmer—no need to flee or worry about inconveniencing others.

How Can This Help You?

You don't need to have a phobia for this imaginative approach to be beneficial. Much of the research tends to spotlight more severe cases, as they are easier to quantify and often come with a stronger motivation to assist individuals in overcoming debilitating responses.

Nonetheless, we all experience certain emotional reactions that we may wish to manage better. Perhaps you’d like to feel less shy when engaging with strangers, less anxious when flirting, or less overwhelmed by fear during exams. Essentially, any everyday emotion that you find challenging can be eased through the power of imagination. Note that this doesn't imply you will never feel these emotions; rather, you may find them more manageable or gain tools to confront them more directly.

For instance, your shyness might stem from a fear of rejection, causing you to shy away from new social interactions. However, if you keep avoiding these situations, your brain won't have the opportunity to learn that, in most cases, people are open to conversation. It also won't recognize that even if you face rejection, it may not be as detrimental as you anticipate.

Imagine initiating a conversation with a stranger and it going well. Then, envision a gentle rejection. This exercise can help your brain understand that the negative outcomes it predicts are not only unlikely but also manageable.

But what if the fears are justified?

For example, anxiety around exams might stem from past experiences with overly critical parents. In this case, your brain might be acting appropriately by inducing stress in preparation for potential negative outcomes.

Thus, the effectiveness of exposure therapy—whether imaginative or real—may be mitigated if the actual negative effects confirm your brain's predictions.

Conversely, if you fear lions instead of dogs, it might be acceptable to maintain that emotional response. After all, a quick reaction could be crucial for your safety. This situation may require deeper introspection to determine whether the emotion itself is the issue or whether it stems from another source.

Nevertheless, both imaginative and real exposure can help lessen your emotional response. You might still feel anxious about exams, but perhaps you won't be paralyzed by fear, frantically scribbling notes and biting your pens. You might experience a more manageable anxiety that allows you to communicate effectively with your parents about your feelings. It's definitely worth a shot.

So, if you find yourself grappling with specific emotional patterns, consider these questions:

• Is this emotion valid?
• Is my brain's prediction of a negative outcome accurate?
• If so, is it as devastating as I fear, or is it something I could handle?
• If the outcome isn't catastrophic, what scenario can I visualize to demonstrate to my brain that it's not the end of the world?
• If the emotion isn't justified, what scenario can I imagine to reassure my brain that the situation is safe?

Once you've reflected on these questions, visualize these scenarios. Close your eyes and immerse yourself in the experience. If you approach this with sincerity, it can be a transformative exercise. Repeat the visualization as often as necessary until you feel ready to confront the real situation.

Photo by Sammie Chaffin on Unsplash

Bibliography

Antony, Martin M., and Richard P. Swinson (2000). Specific Phobia. In Martin M. Antony and Richard P. Swinson (Eds.), Phobic Disorders and Panic in Adults: A Guide to Assessment and Treatment (79–104). American Psychological Association.

Choy, Yujuan., Abby J. Fyer, and Josh D. Lipsitz (2007). Treatment of Specific Phobia in Adults. Clinical Psychology Review, 27, 266–86.

Eaton, William W., O. Joseph Bienvenu, and Beyon Miloyan (2018). Specific Phobias. The Lancet Psychiatry, 5(8), 678–686.

Grayson, Jonathan B. (1982). The Elicitation and Habituation of Orienting and Defensive Responses to Phobic Imagery and the Incremental Stimulus Intensity Effect. Psychophysiology, 19(1), 104–111.

Hackmann, Ann, James Bennett-Levy, and Emily A. Holmes (2011). Oxford Guide to Imagery in Cognitive Therapy. Oxford University Press.

Kosslyn, S. M., Thompson, W. L., & Ganis, G. (2006). The case for mental imagery.

Rivadulla-Duró, Andrea (forthcoming). The Prima Facie View of Perceptual Imagination. Ergo: An Open Access Journal of Philosophy.

Van Leeuwen, N. (2016). The Imaginative Agent. In: Amy Kind & Peter Kung (ed.), Knowledge through Imagination. Oxford University Press. pp. 85–109.